Workers’ Comp Lien and Employer’s Uninsured Motorist Coverage


The Illinois Supreme Court recently decided that a workers’ comp lien does not apply to a recovery on an employer’s uninsured motorist policy under the plain meaning of Illinois workers’ compensation lien statute since there was no recovery from a 3rd party. Taylor v. Pekin Ins. Co., 2008 WL 4943700, --- Ill.2d--- (Nov. 2008).

The Illinois workers’ compensation lien statute clearly creates an employer’s right of reimbursement for any workers compensation benefits paid from any 3rd party recovery. By statute, the workers’ compensation lien applies to any award, judgment, or fund received by an injured employee from a 3rd party. 820 ILCS 305/5(b).

It was decided earlier that a workers comp lien does not attach to an employee’s uninsured motorist coverage (Terry v. State Farm Insurance) (2d Dist.1997) as the uninsured motorist recovery is a contract recovery by the claimant against his or her own insurer and not a recovery against a responsible 3rd party.

By way of background in this case, Taylor filed a workers’ compensation claim for a car accident with an uninsured driver. Plaintiff received $162,588.33 in workers’ compensation benefits. Plaintiff then filed a claim for injuries under the employer’s uninsured motorist policy for the employer’s auto policy issued by Pekin Insurance.

At arbitration on the uninsured motorist claim, Taylor was awarded $250,000. The uninsured motorist policy contained a setoff clause for all sums paid under workers’ compensation so Pekin delivered a check to the plaintiff for $87,411.67 representing the $250,000 arbitration award less the setoff for workers comp benefits paid of $162,588.33.

Taylor filed suit claiming he should get 25% attorney’s fees on the $162,588,33 setoff. The Supreme Court said that Taylor’s claim for attorney’s fees misses the point.

The Supreme Court said the plain language of 5(b) clearly states the workers’ comp lien applies where proceedings are instituted against a person, other than the employer, who is liable for damages. Here the claim was not against a 3rd party so the workers comp lien doesn’t apply. If a workers’ comp lien had applied, the employer would have paid 25% attorney’s fees on any lien reimbursement in order to prevent an unjust enrichment to the employer. (Reno v. Maryland Casualty) (1962). Here, there was no workers’ comp lien to apply and there was no reimbursement of lien but rather a setoff in the auto policy.

The Court said that if Taylor had recovered $250,000 from an actual insured 3rd party, he would have received the same net recovery of $87,411.67 after deducting out the employer’s workers’ compensation lien reimbursement. Plaintiff was left in no better or no worse shape than he would have been in if he had recovered from an insured 3rd party.

Workers’ compensation lien questions should be addressed to Illinois workers’ compensation attorneys knowledgeable in workers’ compensation lien reimbursement.

Chicago Workers Compensation Attorney
-- http://wc-chicago.com 1-26-09


Work Comp Chicago Workers Compensation Attorneys Chicago


Illinois workers compensation lawyers with advanced training and trial experience in Illinois Workers Compensation injury claims and related work injury litigation. Our experience covers all types of work injury claims, medical conditions and related Illinois injury litigation in Chicago and suburban areas since 1984.

Our workers compensation lawyers concentrate in Illinois work injury claims involving construction, manufacturing, health care and transportation.

We have over 20 years of experience in Illinois injury claims covering a broad range of medical conditions including complex fractures, arthroscopic knee and shoulder repairs and advanced experience with back injury claims, disc herniations and spinal fusions.

Aggressive representation in all cases involving loss of occupation, permanent wage reductions or cases of permanent total disability. Our Chicago workers compensation lawyers work with each client to prepare for the expected and anticipate the unexpected. We work to maintain a significant competitive edge in Illinois workers compensation claims and work related injury litigation.

Our attorneys provide instruction, education and preparation available for options in Illinois work injury cases. We provide dedicated, aggressive representation in both Chicago and the surrounding area cities:

Chicago, Waukegan, Barrington, Mundelein, Libertyville, McHenry, Woodstock, Geneva, St. Charles, Elgin, Wheaton, Aurora, Downers Grove, Naperville, Romeoville, Joliet and Kankakee.

Serving greater Chicago and outlying surrounding areas in N.E. Illinois for over 20 years.

For assistance, please contact (312) 541-0049 for conference, meeting,
claim review or consultation.

Chicago Workers Compensation Attorney -- http://wc-chicago.com 1-1-09